Talk:Acid Rain (3.5e Spell)

Comments
There seems to be a lot of information missing with this spell:


 * When does the damage happen?
 * -4 to damage rolls is fine, but it is unclear when a weapon would melt. It's not really obvious when damage reaches a value of 0.
 * Spell Resistance says "See text", but there is no mention of it.

The damage is pretty low, which is probably ok since it has no save.

All in all, this spell just needs some lovin'.


 * Made some edits to address the concerns suggested. I think the damage is a bit low, but yeah, given the lack of a save I thought it was OK for a level 3. - TG Cid 23:40, 17 July 2012 (UTC)


 * Damage still isn't really addressed. What is 0 base damage? Like, if I have a greatsword (2d6 damage), is it done after 2 rounds (7 average damage - 8 < 0) or 3 rounds (12 max damage - 12 = 0)? --Aarnott 15:02, 18 July 2012 (UTC)


 * The intent was when your base damage cannot be positive (so the penalty to base weapon damage would essentially reduce any base damage roll to 0, but not other additions that don't actually come from the weapon itself), the weapon is effectively destroyed. Therefore, the second option that you presented above. - TG Cid 03:58, 19 July 2012 (UTC)


 * More comments! The weapon damage reduction threw me at first, but after digging into it a bit more it seems a reasonable approximation of acid damage effects. Weapons normally take full damage from acid and tend to have surprisingly low hp, so making them die out after a few rounds is basically fine (though I'd argue it's close to -2 per round, not -4). The armor one works similarly, since armor has 5hp per point of AC. Which is about 2 points of AC damage per 3 dice on average, and close enough to the 1 point per round listed. But they don't scale with the damage dice, which is a bit weird.


 * But rather than talk about fix the damage scaling, which I have ideas on, I want to point out that scaling the damage and the duration is weird. It starts off not doing a lot other than melting weapons and armor and chewing through thatch, and winds up melting 20 inches of stone over 2 minutes. I'd scale one or the other, but not both (with my preference being 2d6 acid for 1 rnd / 2 levels, which is close to what it starts as anyway). The long range already does a lot to make it VH on its own.


 * Side note - it makes me sad that the spell can't be repaired by make whole and similar magic. Nevermind. There aren't spells that fix melted or corroded :-(. This oversight makes me sad instead, not acid rain itself, so perhaps I shall go and write some. - Tarkisflux Talk 22:14, 6 September 2012 (UTC)