Talk:Disrupt the Weave (3.5e Maneuver)

Too early?
Interesting maneuver, particularly since it's basically a targeted Greater Dispel Magic as part of a melee attack.

My problem comes in that it comes into play WAAAAAAAY too early. This is a 1st level maneuver, whereas the equivalent (Dispelling Strike, from the Suel Arcanamach) doesn't come into play until 5th level at most. Dispel Magic is a 3rd level spell for many classes, meaning it also comes into play at 5th level. The earliest dispel abjuration is a 1st level spell, but it dispels only wards, not spell effects, and it can't be used to counterspell.

Given how early it enters play, it means any 1st level character gets the ability to dispel ongoing spell effects right from 1st level. IMO, this maneuver could be easily put as a 3rd level maneuver, but without requirements; that way, martial adepts get it at 5th and non-martial adepts can get it through a 6th level feat slot, making it extremely useful. T.G. Oskar (talk) 03:50, 9 November 2012 (UTC)