Difference between revisions of "Talk:Dungeonomicon (3.5e Sourcebook)"

From Dungeons and Dragons Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
(Favor)
m (Updated rating)
Line 12: Line 12:
  
 
Favored! A wonderful supplement, the Dungeonomicom, more than any other book, makes me want to play D&D. Not just any RPG - D&D specifically. New rules fixes, lovely fluff... there's really not much more I can say here. I hope the rest of the RC will back me up on this one, and we can quickly promote this to be both a gold star and our first favored article. [[User:Karrius|Karrius]] 07:22, September 30, 2009 (UTC)  
 
Favored! A wonderful supplement, the Dungeonomicom, more than any other book, makes me want to play D&D. Not just any RPG - D&D specifically. New rules fixes, lovely fluff... there's really not much more I can say here. I hope the rest of the RC will back me up on this one, and we can quickly promote this to be both a gold star and our first favored article. [[User:Karrius|Karrius]] 07:22, September 30, 2009 (UTC)  
 
=== Ghostwheel ===
 
 
Gud stuff is gud. 'Nuff said. -- [[User:Ghostwheel|Ghostwheel]]
 
  
 
== Favor ==
 
== Favor ==
 +
{{RC Favor|rater=Ghostwheel
 +
|points=1
 +
|reason=Lots of good stuff in this sourcebook; I don't necessarily agree with everything, but the sheer amount of great material is definitely a must-read for anyone interested in taking a deeper look behind the design philosophies of D&D.}}
 
{{RC Favor|rater=Tarkisflux
 
{{RC Favor|rater=Tarkisflux
 
|points=2
 
|points=2

Revision as of 19:06, 28 December 2009

-omicon Names?

Why are some of the chapters titled by topic instead of by the -omicon names on the Table of Contents here? I like the -omicon names, and this new way isn't even consistent. --IGTN 02:13, September 28, 2009 (UTC)

Was just going by the Table of Contents in the original work. If it's disliked, I'll change it back. For the sake of consistency, it should probably be changed back. Surgo 02:18, September 28, 2009 (UTC)
Ahh. That makes sense. Charactonomicon gets bumped up since Base Classes and Prestige Classes were originally split over two posts, and Lexiconinomicon replaced Language in D&D because the Lexiconinomicon's first subheading is Language in D&D. --IGTN 02:37, September 28, 2009 (UTC)

Favor

Karrius

Favored! A wonderful supplement, the Dungeonomicom, more than any other book, makes me want to play D&D. Not just any RPG - D&D specifically. New rules fixes, lovely fluff... there's really not much more I can say here. I hope the rest of the RC will back me up on this one, and we can quickly promote this to be both a gold star and our first favored article. Karrius 07:22, September 30, 2009 (UTC)

Favor

Template:RC Favor Template:RC Favor Template:RC Favor Template:RC Favor Template:RC Favor Template:RC Favor

FavoredKarrius +, Tarkisflux +, Jota +, Leziad + and Ganteka Future +
LikedGhostwheel +
UncountedRatingRithaniel + and Sam Kay +