Editing Dungeonomicon (3.5e Sourcebook)/Maginomicon (section)

= The Maginomicon =
{{quote|With great powers come laser eyebeams.}}


== Easter Egg Class Features: Artifact Swords and Powergloves ==

Here's a secret: some characters really can't even play the game at high level. But they do anyway, all the time. Sometimes the players never even realize that their character has no intrinsic capability to play the game at the level he's competing at. And that's because of two things: DMs control the Monsters, and DMs control the Treasure. It is our hope that the Monks and Assassins in this document will be able to hold their own without needing to get Power Gloves that act as magic weapons for their natural weapons or anything else really cheesy like that. That being said, we still haven't covered everything: 

* Rogues still need a magical object that allows them to use the Hide skill by about level 9.
* Fighters still need their artifact swords at level 10.
* Bards still need some completely arbitrary magic item that summons a monster or something so that they can contribute at all past level 12.
* Mounted characters need a magical beast or dragon to ride around on by level 7.

And so on. As this series continues, we will attempt to solve some of these outstanding issues.


== Your Money is No Good Here ==

As described in the Economicon, you can't just throw a walrus' weight in gold on the table and get powerful artifacts in return. You ''can'' get powerful magical items in exchange for rare planar currency, but you can only do that in a few planar locations. From the standpoint of the DM this is very convenient, because it means that you can hand out all the opal statues you want without worrying that the players are going to pool it all and get some totally hardcore magic items that will undermine everything. At the same time, it means that you can hand out planar currency and know for a fact that it's going to be used for powerful magical items.


== It's not Stupid, it's Advanced! ==

The 15,000 gp limit for purchasing equipment can be pretty limiting, but the game works much better once you realize that it's there. Still, while characters can't go out and buy a +4 sword with pieces of gold (all 647 pounds of it), they ''can'' purchase a +1 ''flaming'' or ''ghost touch'' sword with chunks of non-magic metal. You can also pump those up with ''[[SRD:Greater Magic Weapon|greater magic weapon]]'' to be something level appropriate. This offends some people, but it really is part of the way the D&D magic item economy is supposed to work. People are supposed to be fighting with weapons that are level appropriate, and people are supposed to be purchasing new weapons for different occasions, and there are '''not''' supposed to be stores with racks of powerful swords that would be level appropriate for 12th level characters stacked up in various setups on shelves.

* '''Bonus Rule:''' The game actually works better if every character of 6th level or higher simply has ''[[SRD:Greater Magic Weapon|greater magic weapon]]'' 1/day as a spell-like ability. Caster level is equal to character level. Try it, it's amazing how many problems are solved by this relatively simple change.


== Material Components: A Joke Gone ''Way'' Out of Hand ==

Material components are a joke. I'm not saying that they are metaphorically a joke in that they don't act as a consistent or adequate limiting factor to spellcasting, I mean that they are ''actually a joke''. Material components are supposed to be "ha ha" funny. The fact that even after having this brought to your attention, you still aren't laughing, indicates that this is a failed attempt at humor. Most material components are based on technological gags: when you cast ''scrying'', you are literally supposed to grab yourself a "specially treated" mirror, some wire, and some lemons – which is to say that you make a TV set to watch your target on and then power it with an archaic battery. When you cast ''see invisibility'', you literally blow talc all over the place – which of course reveals invisible foes. Casting ''lightning bolt'' requires you to generate a static charge with an amber rod and some fur, ''tongues'' requires that you build a little Tower of Babel, and of course ''fireball'' requires that you whip up some actual gunpowder. Get it? You're making the effects MacGuyver style and then claiming that it's "magic" after the fact. Are you laughing yet?

Of course not, because that joke is incredibly lame and there's no way for it to hold your attention for several months of a continuous campaign.

== Some Spells Don't Work ==

Many spells are underwhelming for their level or have mechanics that are hard to explain. But first and foremost of all the spells that are bad for the game is ''[[SRD:Polymorph|Polymorph]]''. That spell is integral to any fantasy setting, but people haven't made it work in 3rd edition. Mostly, this is because people keep writing it ''long'' instead of ''short''. Remember, if you can't explain an effect in 2 minutes, everyone else is already confused.


=== Polymorph Version 1: Character Replacement ===

If you take part of your character – ''any'' part of your character – and part of a monster from one of the many monster books in <u>D&D</u>, and you put them together into a single <u>Voltron</u>-like body, you have broken <u>D&D</u>. That should be obvious, but since we are over six years into the ridiculous circus that is ''[[SRD:Polymorph|polymorph]]'' in 3rd edition <u>Dungeons and Dragons</u>, apparently it isn't. If it is important to you that you be allowed to dumpster dive through the monster books and find an appropriate monster to transform into, it is important to <u>D&D</u> that absolutely no part of your character be mixed and matched during that period. If you want to truly become a monster, you have to ''actually'' become that monster. Not "the monster with all my spell effects running", not "the monster with my formidable mental attributes. No. You need to become the monster ''exactly'' as it appears in the monster book or there's no chance of you getting a balanced result. Some people are going to end up as mediocre monsters with carry-over abilities that happen to synergize well and become tremendously powerful while other people are just as unbalanced in the other direction when they find that drawbacks of their character are carried over and overwrite the abilities of a monster that are supposed to make them any good at all.

And this isn't just hyperbole or doomsday predictions, this is established fact. We've all played with some of the multitude of different versions of Polymorph errata and "fixes", and the abject horror caused by every single iteration. The ''idea'' doesn't work. If you're going to replace any part of the character, you have to replace it all. So here's a version of ''polymorph'' that won't make us cry. This ain't rocket science, it just takes a little bit of discipline:

{{:Polymorph Self, Tome (3.5e Spell)}}

{{:Polymorph Other, Tome (3.5e Spell)}}

{{:Mass Polymorph, Tome (3.5e Spell)}}

=== Polymorph Version 2: Fixed Forms ===

The other version is one where transforming leaves you essentially yourself, only with a new hairdo and possibly some bonuses. In this case, you keep everything about yourself and simply get a disguise and some advantages consistent with a buff spell. All of the "Whatever-Form" spells don't stack with multiple castings or even with each other, because they are considered to be "one spell makes another spell irrelevant" for purposes of spell stacking.

{{:Human Form (3.5e Spell)}}

{{:Lycanthropy (3.5e Spell)}}

{{:Monstrous Form (3.5e Spell)}}

{{:Fiend Form (3.5e Spell)}}

{{:Dragon Form (3.5e Spell)}}

== Some Effects Don't Work ==

=== Stacking Spell Resistance ===

Spell Resistance does stack, but it does so in a really weird way that the authors have never actually taken the time to explain. SR is a DC for a level check, and that means that it is actually calculated as the number people are supposed to roll to penetrate your SR ''plus your CR''. A SR of 15 on a CR 1 monster is awesome (it means that people of your level are supposed to roll a 14 to penetrate your SR), while a SR of 15 for a CR 13 monster is a joke (it means that enemies fail to penetrate your SR only on a natural 1). When you have Spell Resistance, and your CR goes up, your Spell Resistance also goes up. An Imp with a CR of 2 and a SR of 6 who takes enough levels of Wizard to gain a CR (2 levels as it happens) gains 1 SR as well and is SR 7.

But what happens if more than one source gives you SR? Well, it still stacks, it just does so in the aforementioned really weird way. First, you take your highest SR, then you start adding very small numbers to it based on what your other sources of SR would give you. If a secondary source of SR is less than 6 + your CR, having it increases your SR by +1. If a secondary source of SR is 6 + your CR or more, but less than 11 + our CR, your primary SR increases by +2. If a secondary source of SR is between 11 + CR and 15 + CR, it increases the primary SR by +3. And finally, a secondary source of SR that is 16 + CR or more adds +4 to the primary SR. 

It would be nice if the basic rules ever explained that, but they don't. It doesn't come up all that often, but Drow Monks, for example, don't end up with SR in the high 30s at mid level. Their SR is actually just moderately impressive.


=== Hiding in 3.5 D&D is Dumb ===

OK, we all know that it makes us feel kind of bad when the Rogue sneaks up on people and stabs them in the face without them ever seeing who did it. But you know what? People totally do that crap all the time. It's not even an uncommon occurrence, and there's really no cause to get excited about. The 3.5 rules for hiding, where you need cover or concealment to hide, are retarded. That makes Rogues run around with tower shields so that they can hide themselves and their equipment behind the cover of the tower shield (including the tower shield itself, which makes my brain hurt). Yes, you can totally hide when there are no intervening objects between you and the victim. It's called "sneaking up behind people" and in a game with no facing it's handled with a hide check opposed by spot.

If you attempt to hide in a combat setting, you are under a number of restrictions:

* A character who has been attacked automatically can guess what square you are in. You may retain your invisibility, but that's just Full Concealment, and they could very plausibly hit you.
* There is a -20 penalty to Hide for attempting to fight while hidden. The distance penalties on Spot are pretty amazing, but most people can't hide at a -20 penalty.
* Once they see you, they see you. If an opponent successfully spots you even once (and they get to try every round while in combat), they just plain see you until you manage to get all the way out of their field of view (generally requiring you to leave the scene or make bluff checks or something).
* Spot Bonuses can get quite large. A spotter who knows what he's looking for gets a +4 bonus, and a spotter who is extremely familiar with the target gets a +10 bonus – these bonuses are weirdly listed under the Disguise skill, but they still apply (so if someone says "There's a halfling Ninja over there!" every other Guard gets a +4 bonus).

But you ''can'' do it. Hiding in combat is ''hard'', but it's a thing that powerful characters may be able to do against some opponents. Some of the D&D authors have an outdated idea that Rogues should be forced to "hide in shadows" or something. But this is D&D, and most enemies have Darkvision. There ''are'' no shadows. Attempting to force Rogues to hide only in areas that they could plausibly hide in if a suspicious person was looking right at them and knew what they were looking for is incredibly cruel. In any kind of stressful situation that isn't an accurate picture of what is going on.


=== Clerics and Druids get Broken with Supplements ===

Sometimes it seems that WotC authors can't even write a supplement without writing a new Cleric spell. Unfortunately, that drives Clerics straight into crazy town because they actually know every spell on their list. So if someone writes 5 new cleric spells for a minor adventure, that's five new options that every Cleric player has for no reason. That has to stop.

Characters like Clerics and Druids are, with few exceptions (*cough*''[[SRD:Divine Power|divine power]]''*cough*) pretty much OK with the spells in the Player's Handbook. It's only when we mix in all the crazy options in additional sources that they go over-the-top. It is our contention, then, that such characters continue to be allowed access to all spells in the PHB – and to only get one bonus known spell from other sourcebooks each level (choose wisely). In this manner, the Clerics and druids of the world will end up having a couple of specific gimmicks, and they won't all just be cookie-cutter copies of each other with an answer for every occasion. Thereafter, such characters could potentially find magical writings with new spells in their discipline that they could learn and use in the same manner as a Wizard. I have nothing against a Druid finding a copy of some ancient text that allows her to call upon the legendary ''bloodsnow'', but it's pretty ridiculous the way in the current rules every Druid can get up one day and decide to have an explosion of ''bloodsnow''.


----
{{3.5e Dungeonomicon Breadcrumb}}
Component	V + and S +
Level	Sorcerer/Wizard 4 +, Sorcerer/Wizard 7 +, Bard 1 +, Sorcerer/Wizard 2 +, Sorcerer/Wizard 3 +, Sorcerer/Wizard 5 + and Sorcerer/Wizard 6 +
Range	Personal +, Medium + and Touch +
School	Transmutation +
Summary	You are transformed into a creature of your choosing. +, Target is transformed into an alternate creature (revised polymorph). +, Multiple targets are transformed into alternate creatures. +, Target assumes appearance and form of a humanoid. +, Target takes on the form of an animal or magical beast. +, Target assumes the form of a monster. +, Target gains form of a fiendish race, as well as some of their abilities. + and The target assumes the form of a huge dragon. +