Difference between revisions of "Talk:Baron of the Grave (3.5e Prestige Class)"
From Dungeons and Dragons Wiki
(added favor) |
|||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
|reason=Nice fluff, well written. Straightforward class. Semi-transformative in nature, so, it should maintain its appeal to most players who get turned off. Really, this is lich-esque material here (in spirit). Lending toward still being what the character was before, and adding to it. So, its powerful of course, but none of the powers exceed beyond what would be expected of a wizard anyhow. Spell per day limited class abilities are nice for filling out the flavor (so the character doesn't have to rely on stored spells for such things). Of course, judging the effectiveness of a class by reading it is difficult, but everything appears to be in order. However, it really doesn't bring anything exiting or fancy to the table that will really draw someone in for a play (which doesn't feel like the intention here anyhow). So, a bit of a close call for me, but in the end, nice work. | |reason=Nice fluff, well written. Straightforward class. Semi-transformative in nature, so, it should maintain its appeal to most players who get turned off. Really, this is lich-esque material here (in spirit). Lending toward still being what the character was before, and adding to it. So, its powerful of course, but none of the powers exceed beyond what would be expected of a wizard anyhow. Spell per day limited class abilities are nice for filling out the flavor (so the character doesn't have to rely on stored spells for such things). Of course, judging the effectiveness of a class by reading it is difficult, but everything appears to be in order. However, it really doesn't bring anything exiting or fancy to the table that will really draw someone in for a play (which doesn't feel like the intention here anyhow). So, a bit of a close call for me, but in the end, nice work. | ||
}} | }} | ||
| + | {{RC Favor | ||
| + | |rater=DanielDraco | ||
| + | |points=2 | ||
| + | |reason=Mechanically, this is a pretty good class. It makes necromancy quite a bit more viable than it normally is, although I feel it could do a little more to that end if it wants to put an undead-centric character on par with other sorts of spellcaster. However, it certainly isn't weaker than a wizard, so it hits its balance point adequately. What really propels this page to excellency is the fact that it's absolutely '''dripping''' with flavor; this class is excellently described, and leaves a perfect mental image of what a Baron of the Grave is supposed to be. For that reason, this article is certainly notable enough to be "excellent".}} | ||
